Army Field Band Percussion/Drum Set

might have something to do with less and less orchestral percussionists having extensive drumset experience. someone who can do both at a really high level is harder to come by now

Are orchestral percussionists typically great drumset players? No.

Could a lot of them still function just fine in a large ensemble setting, like an orchestra or concert band? Yes.

I dunno if the Field Band often breaks out into smaller ensembles (like jazz/rock/fusion groups) when they work, but if that’s the case then they should’ve probably advertised it as a drumset audition and also ask for some “classical” skills to be demonstrated. I’m pretty sure the Marine Band (also had a no-hire for a perc+drumset job recently) does not do the small group thing.

But if they’re just looking for someone to play boom-chick on some Broadway/pop charts or whatever, then they’re probably placing too much emphasis on the drumset stuff and passing over great orchestral players who would be solid contributors in their band.